Evaluating the breach of duty in cardiology: applying the Bolitho test

Medical professional in scrubs reviewing documents at an office desk.
Photo by https://kaboompics.com/ via Pexels

In cardiology litigation, the assessment of whether a clinician has fallen below the expected standard of care rests upon the interaction between clinical practice and the court’s evaluation of that practice under the Bolitho test. For solicitors, understanding how an expert applies this test is essential when the dispute centres on the reasonableness of clinical choices rather than a simple failure to perform a known procedure.

The Bolitho limitation on the Bolam standard

The standard of care remains defined by the Bolam test, which measures the practitioner’s conduct against a responsible body of medical opinion. However, the decision in Bolitho v City and Hackney Health Authority [1998] established that a court will not accept a body of opinion as responsible if it cannot withstand logical analysis. When an expert prepares a detailed breach of duty cardiology report, they must articulate the rationale for their position in a way that demonstrates the clinical logic behind the choices made. This requires the expert to address whether the action or omission was grounded in a sound understanding of the underlying cardiac physiology, rather than merely stating that other cardiologists might have acted similarly.

Establishing the clinical standard

An expert opinion on breach must identify the specific standard applicable at the time of the alleged incident. Hindsight bias is a consistent challenge in cardiology claims, particularly where an adverse cardiac event follows a diagnostic decision. The evidence must evaluate whether the treatment plan was reasonable based on the information available to the clinician at the point of care, rather than the subsequent clinical outcome. Where a practitioner failed to recognise the significance of ECG changes or cardiac markers, the expert must explain why the interpretation of those specific findings would have been recognised as aberrant by a competent body of peers at that time.

The role of the evidential base

The strength of a cardiology expert’s opinion is dependent on the quality of the evidential base. This includes:

  • Original raw imaging data, such as coronary angiograms or echocardiography loops, rather than secondary interpretations.
  • Comprehensive primary care records to establish the patient’s longitudinal cardiac history and pre-existing risk factors.
  • Full hospital admission notes, including nursing observations that may capture clinical deterioration.
  • Pharmacological records to confirm the timing and dosage of medications such as antiplatelets or anticoagulants.

Where key records are missing, the expert must state this explicitly. A report that attempts to infer clinical decisions in the absence of primary evidence is vulnerable to challenge under the requirement for logical and robust reasoning.

Discipline boundaries in cardiac litigation

Cardiology often overlaps with other medical disciplines, and identifying the scope of the cardiology opinion is critical. For instance, the management of a stroke following a cardiac procedure involves a boundary between the cardiologist and the neurologist. Similarly, the interpretation of surgical risk in a patient with multi-system comorbidities may require a collaborative approach with an anaesthetist. If the core dispute concerns the surgical technique employed during a percutaneous coronary intervention, an interventional cardiologist is the appropriate witness. However, if the dispute involves the appropriateness of informed consent, the opinion must be framed within the Montgomery v Lanarkshire Health Board [2015] requirement to disclose material risks, a duty that remains independent of the technical excellence of the procedure.

Procedural mechanisms in England and Wales

Under CPR Part 35, the expert’s primary duty is to the court. When experts are instructed by both claimant and defendant, the process of reaching a joint statement under CPR 35.12 serves to narrow the issues. This process identifies areas of professional agreement and disagreement. Should the experts reach an impasse, Practice Direction 35 requires that the reasons for disagreement be clearly articulated. Instructing solicitors may use CPR 35.6 to pose written questions to an expert, provided these are used to clarify the report rather than to embark on cross-examination. Where a single joint expert is instructed under CPR 35.7, their appointment is governed by the provisions of CPR 35.8. The evaluation of evidence depends on whether the expert’s reasoning addresses the specific clinical dilemma identified in the pleading.

This article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal or medical advice. Readers should seek appropriate professional guidance.

Similar Posts