Causation of peripheral nerve damage in foot and ankle surgery: forensic analysis of the operative note

A medical professional in scrubs and mask examines documents in a clinical setting.
Photo by https://kaboompics.com/ via Pexels

The evidentiary weight of the operative note

In England and Wales, an expert report under CPR Part 35 must be grounded in available clinical documentation. The operative note serves as the primary record for evaluating the standard of care and the specific steps taken to protect local structures. A lack of specific mention of nerve identification or retraction in the note does not, of itself, demonstrate a departure from the Bolam standard as qualified by Bolitho. However, where an operative note is sparse or lacks a detailed account of the approach and dissection, an expert faces limitations in assessing whether the surgeon identified and safely managed relevant nerves, such as the sural or superficial peroneal nerves.

To support a claim, the evidential base should include:

  • Pre-operative imaging to establish the anatomical position of nerves in relation to the intended incision.
  • The full operative note, including the surgeon’s description of the incision, the method of retraction, and any documented anatomical variations encountered.
  • Post-operative neurology clinic notes, detailing the onset of symptoms and sensory testing results.
  • Electrodiagnostic reports, such as nerve conduction studies, to assist in differentiating between types of nerve injury.

Where the operative note is deficient, the expert must clearly state this limitation in their report, acknowledging the necessity of relying upon the claimant’s account of post-operative symptoms alongside objective findings during later clinical examinations.

Applying the Bolam and Bolitho standards to surgical technique

The assessment of breach of duty involves determining whether the surgical approach was consistent with the practice of a responsible body of foot and ankle surgeons. Under Bolam, the expert must state whether the identified technique was accepted as proper by a relevant group of professionals. Bolitho allows the court to challenge this where the expert’s opinion lacks a logical basis. In the context of peripheral nerve damage, this often centres on whether the surgeon took reasonable precautions to avoid nerve compression or traction during the dissection or the placement of internal fixation devices.

If the evidence suggests that a nerve was transected, the question is whether the location of the incision was within a standard anatomical range, or if the surgeon failed to recognise or avoid the structure. An adverse outcome does not, in isolation, equate to negligence. Expert opinion must distinguish between an unfortunate but recognised complication of surgery—where the informed consent process is central under the Montgomery framework—and a failure to perform the surgery with reasonable skill and care.

Causation analysis in nerve injury claims

Proving causation requires the claimant to establish that the negligent act, rather than the underlying condition or a non-negligent complication, caused the nerve injury. This involves an ordinary but-for analysis. If the nerve damage would have occurred notwithstanding the alleged negligence, causation is not established. Material contribution arguments are only relevant in specific circumstances where there are multiple, potentially independent causes of damage. Experts must be wary of equating the presence of a symptom with proof of a specific surgical error.

Discipline boundaries and the handover of evidence

A dispute concerning nerve damage often requires cross-specialty evidence. While an orthopaedic or podiatric surgeon evaluates the procedural aspects and breach of duty, a consultant neurologist or neurophysiologist is often required to assess the severity of the nerve damage and the prognosis for recovery. The surgical expert identifies the mechanism—such as traction, thermal injury, or direct trauma—while the neurologist quantifies the functional impact.

When instructing an expert, it is necessary to consider whether the primary question is one of surgical technique, or whether the prognosis for neuropathic pain requires a specialist neurologist or pain management expert. An expert who attempts to stray beyond their clinical discipline risks falling foul of the overriding duty to the court under CPR 35.3. When two experts are instructed, a joint statement under CPR 35.12 may be directed by the court to provide clarity on areas of agreement and disagreement. In cases where a single joint expert is appointed, instructions should be provided in accordance with CPR 35.8.

The value of a claim for future care is frequently contingent on the expert’s assessment of whether the prognosis is fixed or subject to further review. If nerve regeneration remains uncertain, the expert must clarify the timeline for when a definitive prognosis can be reached. The court requires this evidence to be presented in a manner that distinguishes between current clinical findings and long-term functional expectations.

This article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal or medical advice. Readers should seek appropriate professional guidance.

Similar Posts